Mixed-Use Investment in Columbus
Columbus mixed-use deals are having a moment. Intel's $20B chip fab commitment has every institutional investor paying attention, but the real action's in transit-oriented development around COTA's BRT lines and Ohio State's continued expansion. We're seeing blended cap rates in the 5.5%-7.5% range depending on submarket and residential component quality. The tricky part? Most buyers still don't know how to underwrite these properly. They'll throw a single cap rate at blended NOI instead of breaking out components. Your OM needs to do the work for them.
Market Context
Cap Rate Range
5.5%-7.5% blended, with residential components trading at 5.2%-6.0% and retail at 6.5%-8.5%
Current Vacancy
8-12% retail component, 4-7% residential component depending on submarket
Rent Trend
Residential up 6-9% YoY in core submarkets, retail holding flat except for food/beverage concepts
Absorption
Strong for 1BR/2BR units in walkable locations, slower for ground-floor retail outside established corridors
Price Per Unit Trend
Residential component averaging $180K-$250K per door based on location and finishes
Transaction Volume
Limited comp set - maybe 8-12 true mixed-use trades annually, most under $25M
Submarket Analysis
Short North
5.5%-6.2% capVacancy
3-5% residential, 8-12% retail
Avg Rent (1BR)
$1,400-$1,650
Prime location with established foot traffic. New supply coming but absorption stays strong.
OM Tip
Emphasize walkability scores and proximity to conventions/downtown employment
German Village/Brewery District
6.0%-6.8% capVacancy
5-8% residential, 10-15% retail
Avg Rent (1BR)
$1,200-$1,450
Historic charm draws tenants but retail space can be challenging to fill.
OM Tip
Historic tax credits and zoning restrictions need clear explanation
University District
6.2%-7.0% capVacancy
6-9% residential, 12-18% retail
Avg Rent (1BR)
$1,100-$1,350
Student housing component provides stability but limits upside potential.
OM Tip
Break out student vs young professional tenant mix clearly
Franklinton
6.5%-7.5% capVacancy
8-12% residential, 15-25% retail
Avg Rent (1BR)
$950-$1,250
Emerging area with development incentives but still proving retail viability.
OM Tip
Highlight city incentives and future development pipeline
Grandview/Upper Arlington
5.8%-6.5% capVacancy
4-7% residential, 6-10% retail
Avg Rent (1BR)
$1,300-$1,550
Affluent demographics support both components well.
OM Tip
Demographics and household income data essential for retail component
Performance by Vintage
0
P
1
r
2
e
3
-
4
2
5
0
6
0
7
0
8
9
p
10
r
11
o
12
p
13
e
14
r
15
t
16
i
17
e
18
s
19
20
o
21
f
22
t
23
e
24
n
25
26
h
27
a
28
v
29
e
30
31
c
32
h
33
a
34
l
35
l
36
e
37
n
38
g
39
i
40
n
41
g
42
43
r
44
e
45
t
46
a
47
i
48
l
49
50
l
51
a
52
y
53
o
54
u
55
t
56
s
57
58
a
59
n
60
d
61
62
r
63
e
64
q
65
u
66
i
67
r
68
e
69
70
s
71
i
72
g
73
n
74
i
75
f
76
i
77
c
78
a
79
n
80
t
81
82
c
83
a
84
p
85
i
86
t
87
a
88
l
89
90
f
91
o
92
r
93
94
m
95
o
96
d
97
e
98
r
99
n
100
101
m
102
i
103
x
104
e
105
d
106
-
107
u
108
s
109
e
110
111
f
112
u
113
n
114
c
115
t
116
i
117
o
118
n
119
a
120
l
121
i
122
t
123
y
124
.
125
126
2
127
0
128
0
129
0
130
-
131
2
132
0
133
1
134
0
135
136
d
137
e
138
v
139
e
140
l
141
o
142
p
143
m
144
e
145
n
146
t
147
s
148
149
f
150
r
151
e
152
q
153
u
154
e
155
n
156
t
157
l
158
y
159
160
o
161
v
162
e
163
r
164
-
165
b
166
u
167
i
168
l
169
t
170
171
r
172
e
173
t
174
a
175
i
176
l
177
178
s
179
p
180
a
181
c
182
e
183
184
r
185
e
186
l
187
a
188
t
189
i
190
v
191
e
192
193
t
194
o
195
196
m
197
a
198
r
199
k
200
e
201
t
202
203
d
204
e
205
m
206
a
207
n
208
d
209
.
210
211
2
212
0
213
1
214
0
215
-
216
2
217
0
218
2
219
0
220
221
p
222
r
223
o
224
j
225
e
226
c
227
t
228
s
229
230
s
231
h
232
o
233
w
234
235
b
236
e
237
t
238
t
239
e
240
r
241
242
r
243
e
244
s
245
i
246
d
247
e
248
n
249
t
250
i
251
a
252
l
253
/
254
r
255
e
256
t
257
a
258
i
259
l
260
261
r
262
a
263
t
264
i
265
o
266
s
267
268
b
269
u
270
t
271
272
m
273
a
274
y
275
276
n
277
e
278
e
279
d
280
281
p
282
a
283
r
284
k
285
i
286
n
287
g
288
289
a
290
d
291
j
292
u
293
s
294
t
295
m
296
e
297
n
298
t
299
s
300
301
f
302
o
303
r
304
305
c
306
h
307
a
308
n
309
g
310
i
311
n
312
g
313
314
c
315
o
316
m
317
m
318
u
319
t
320
e
321
322
p
323
a
324
t
325
t
326
e
327
r
328
n
329
s
330
.
331
332
P
333
o
334
s
335
t
336
-
337
2
338
0
339
2
340
0
341
342
d
343
e
344
v
345
e
346
l
347
o
348
p
349
m
350
e
351
n
352
t
353
s
354
355
i
356
n
357
c
358
o
359
r
360
p
361
o
362
r
363
a
364
t
365
e
366
367
f
368
o
369
o
370
d
371
372
h
373
a
374
l
375
l
376
377
c
378
o
379
n
380
c
381
e
382
p
383
t
384
s
385
386
a
387
n
388
d
389
390
f
391
l
392
e
393
x
394
i
395
b
396
l
397
e
398
399
r
400
e
401
t
402
a
403
i
404
l
405
406
s
407
p
408
a
409
c
410
e
411
412
b
413
u
414
t
415
416
c
417
o
418
m
419
m
420
a
421
n
422
d
423
424
p
425
r
426
e
427
m
428
i
429
u
430
m
431
432
p
433
r
434
i
435
c
436
i
437
n
438
g
439
.
What Your OM Needs to Address
Component-Level Financial Analysis
Break out P&L by use type with separate cap rate analysis for each component
Data to Include
Individual rent rolls, expense allocation methodology, separate market comparables for each use type
Parking Analysis
Mixed-use parking ratios differ from single-use - show actual utilization patterns by time of day
Data to Include
Parking counts by hour, resident vs retail customer usage, shared parking credit calculations
Zoning and Development Rights
Columbus has specific mixed-use zoning incentives that affect valuation and expansion potential
Data to Include
Current zoning classification, FAR utilization, available development rights, TIF district status
Tenant Mix Stability
Retail tenant credit and lease terms significantly impact overall property risk profile
Data to Include
Tenant sales data where available, lease expiration schedule, percentage rent performance, local vs national tenant breakdown
Transit and Walkability Metrics
COTA BRT proximity and Walk Score directly correlate with rental premium and retail performance
Data to Include
Walk Score, transit proximity maps, pedestrian traffic counts, bike lane access
Capital Improvement Schedule
Mixed-use properties have complex maintenance schedules affecting both residential and retail components
Data to Include
Separate capex schedules by component, shared system maintenance costs, retail buildout allowances
Investment Outlook
Short Term
Intel announcement has created supply pressure in certain submarkets but demand remains strong for well-located projects. Retail component performance varies significantly by location - food/beverage concepts outperforming traditional retail. Construction costs still elevated but stabilizing.
Medium Term
BRT expansion should benefit properties along high-frequency corridors. Ohio State's continued growth provides stable demand base for University District projects. Retail space may need to be reimagined for changing consumer patterns - expect more service-oriented and experience-based tenants.
Long Term
Columbus's position in the semiconductor supply chain creates long-term demographic tailwinds. Mixed-use development likely becomes standard in urban core rather than specialty product type. Properties with flexible ground-floor space and strong transit connections should outperform.
Buyer Profile
Regional funds and local developers dominate the market. Some coastal capital starting to pay attention post-Intel but still limited. Owner-users common for smaller projects. REITs largely absent due to deal size and complexity.
Marketing a mixed-use property in Columbus?
DealDraft generates professional offering memorandums with market-specific data and property-type expertise built in.
Create Your OM