Senior Living Investment in Indianapolis
Indianapolis senior living's getting interesting. Baby boomers hit 85 at record pace while new construction basically stopped during COVID. Occupancy's back above 90% for quality operators, and buyers are paying up for assets with solid payor mix. The Eli Lilly expansion's creating wealth that filters into private-pay demand, but Medicaid rates still lag peer markets. If you're selling, your OM better break out performance by acuity level — buyers won't accept blended numbers anymore.
Market Context
Cap Rate Range
6.75% to 8.25% depending on location and care mix. Independent living trades tightest at 6.75-7.25%. Memory care and skilled nursing push toward 8%+.
Current Vacancy
8.5% market-wide, down from 12% peak in 2022. Independent living runs tighter at 6-7% while assisted living still sees 9-11% in older properties.
Rent Trend
Private pay rates up 4.2% year-over-year. Independent living leads at $2,800-3,200/month, assisted living $4,100-4,800, memory care $5,200-6,000.
Absorption
145 net absorptions in 2025, strongest in three years. Memory care absorbed 65 units, assisted living 52 units, independent living 28 units.
Price Per Unit Trend
Quality assets trading $185K-220K per unit, up 8% from 2024. Memory care commands premium at $240K+ per unit for newer properties.
Transaction Volume
$145M in 2025, up from $95M in 2024. Mix shifted toward larger portfolio deals as REITs consolidated smaller operators.
Submarket Analysis
Carmel/North Indianapolis
6.5-7.0% capVacancy
5.5%
Avg Rent (1BR)
$3,100 IL / $4,600 AL
Strongest submarket. Eli Lilly wealth effect supports private pay. Limited land for new development.
OM Tip
Highlight proximity to St. Vincent Carmel and community hospital network access.
Fishers/East Side
6.75-7.25% capVacancy
7.2%
Avg Rent (1BR)
$2,950 IL / $4,400 AL
Growing retiree population from tech and life sciences. New supply coming online in 2027.
OM Tip
Document demographic trends and compare to state Medicaid penetration rates.
Zionsville/Northwest
6.5-7.0% capVacancy
6.8%
Avg Rent (1BR)
$3,200 IL / $4,750 AL
Premium market with strong private pay penetration. Limited competition from national operators.
OM Tip
Emphasize private pay percentages and waitlist dynamics for memory care.
Greenwood/South Side
7.5-8.0% capVacancy
11.2%
Avg Rent (1BR)
$2,650 IL / $3,900 AL
Higher Medicaid penetration pressures margins. Value-add opportunities for experienced operators.
OM Tip
Include detailed payor mix breakdown and Medicaid rate history.
Downtown/Near West
7.25-7.75% capVacancy
9.1%
Avg Rent (1BR)
$2,800 IL / $4,200 AL
Mixed demand. Proximity to IU Health and Methodist appeals to some, but neighborhood concerns limit premium positioning.
OM Tip
Address transportation access and highlight hospital partnerships.
Performance by Vintage
0
2
1
0
2
1
3
0
4
s
5
6
p
7
r
8
o
9
p
10
e
11
r
12
t
13
i
14
e
15
s
16
17
t
18
r
19
a
20
d
21
e
22
23
a
24
t
25
26
6
27
.
28
7
29
5
30
-
31
7
32
.
33
2
34
5
35
%
36
37
c
38
a
39
p
40
s
41
42
w
43
i
44
t
45
h
46
47
m
48
o
49
d
50
e
51
r
52
n
53
54
l
55
a
56
y
57
o
58
u
59
t
60
s
61
62
t
63
h
64
a
65
t
66
67
s
68
u
69
p
70
p
71
o
72
r
73
t
74
75
a
76
g
77
i
78
n
79
g
80
-
81
i
82
n
83
-
84
p
85
l
86
a
87
c
88
e
89
.
90
91
2
92
0
93
0
94
0
95
s
96
97
v
98
i
99
n
100
t
101
a
102
g
103
e
104
105
n
106
e
107
e
108
d
109
s
110
111
c
112
a
113
p
114
i
115
t
116
a
117
l
118
119
f
120
o
121
r
122
123
c
124
o
125
m
126
m
127
o
128
n
129
130
a
131
r
132
e
133
a
134
135
r
136
e
137
f
138
r
139
e
140
s
141
h
142
e
143
s
144
145
b
146
u
147
t
148
149
b
150
o
151
n
152
e
153
s
154
155
a
156
r
157
e
158
159
s
160
o
161
l
162
i
163
d
164
165
—
166
167
e
168
x
169
p
170
e
171
c
172
t
173
174
7
175
.
176
2
177
5
178
-
179
7
180
.
181
7
182
5
183
%
184
185
c
186
a
187
p
188
s
189
.
190
191
1
192
9
193
9
194
0
195
s
196
197
a
198
s
199
s
200
e
201
t
202
s
203
204
r
205
e
206
q
207
u
208
i
209
r
210
e
211
212
m
213
a
214
j
215
o
216
r
217
218
H
219
V
220
A
221
C
222
223
a
224
n
225
d
226
227
l
228
i
229
f
230
e
231
232
s
233
a
234
f
235
e
236
t
237
y
238
239
u
240
p
241
g
242
r
243
a
244
d
245
e
246
s
247
,
248
249
p
250
u
251
s
252
h
253
i
254
n
255
g
256
257
b
258
u
259
y
260
e
261
r
262
s
263
264
t
265
o
266
w
267
a
268
r
269
d
270
271
8
272
%
273
+
274
275
r
276
e
277
t
278
u
279
r
280
n
281
s
282
.
283
284
1
285
9
286
8
287
0
288
s
289
290
p
291
r
292
o
293
p
294
e
295
r
296
t
297
i
298
e
299
s
300
301
m
302
o
303
s
304
t
305
l
306
y
307
308
t
309
r
310
a
311
n
312
s
313
i
314
t
315
i
316
o
317
n
318
i
319
n
320
g
321
322
t
323
o
324
325
s
326
k
327
i
328
l
329
l
330
e
331
d
332
333
n
334
u
335
r
336
s
337
i
338
n
339
g
340
341
o
342
r
343
344
f
345
a
346
c
347
i
348
n
349
g
350
351
r
352
e
353
d
354
e
355
v
356
e
357
l
358
o
359
p
360
m
361
e
362
n
363
t
364
365
p
366
r
367
e
368
s
369
s
370
u
371
r
372
e
373
.
What Your OM Needs to Address
Care Level Performance Breakdown
Buyers won't accept blended occupancy or revenue numbers anymore. Break out independent living, assisted living, and memory care separately.
Data to Include
Monthly occupancy by care level for 36 months, average length of stay by acuity, move-in/move-out patterns by care type.
Staffing Cost Analysis
Labor represents 60%+ of operating expenses. Document current staffing ratios, wage trends, and turnover rates.
Data to Include
Staff-to-resident ratios by shift, average hourly wages by position, turnover percentages, agency vs. full-time staff mix.
Payor Mix Documentation
Private pay sustainability drives valuations. Show historical trends and market positioning against Medicaid-dependent competitors.
Data to Include
Monthly private pay percentages by care level, Medicaid wait times, private pay rate increases by year.
Regulatory Compliance Status
Indiana's licensing requirements and survey history matter for financing and operations continuity.
Data to Include
Most recent state survey results, any outstanding citations, licensing renewal dates, fire safety compliance.
Capital Expenditure Schedule
Buyers model major repairs and replacements differently than other property types due to ADA and life safety requirements.
Data to Include
HVAC replacement schedule, elevator maintenance contracts, kitchen equipment age, life safety system upgrade timeline.
Market Penetration Analysis
Indianapolis has pockets of oversupply and underserved areas. Position your asset within competitive radius analysis.
Data to Include
Competitor occupancy rates within 3-mile radius, planned new supply, demographic projections for 75+ population.
Investment Outlook
Short Term
2026-2027 looks solid for quality operators. Occupancy recovery continues while new supply remains limited. Expect cap rate compression for well-located assets with strong private pay mix.
Medium Term
2027-2029 brings new supply pressure, particularly in Fishers and Carmel. Operators with differentiated programming and strong clinical outcomes will maintain pricing power. Consolidation continues as smaller operators struggle with labor costs.
Long Term
2030+ demographic wave is real — 85+ population grows 35% through 2035. But regulatory changes around Medicaid funding and potential Medicare Advantage shifts create uncertainty. Properties positioned for private pay will outperform.
Buyer Profile
Regional operators dominating deals under $25M. REITs active for portfolio acquisitions $50M+. Private equity backing experienced operators for value-add plays, especially assets needing acuity repositioning or operational improvements.
Marketing a senior living property in Indianapolis?
DealDraft generates professional offering memorandums with market-specific data and property-type expertise built in.
Create Your OM