Single-Tenant Net Lease Investment in Indianapolis
Indianapolis' single-tenant net lease market runs on two engines: national credit tenants chasing yield compression and regional operators offering higher returns with manageable risk. The I-465 corridor drives most of the volume, with drugstores and QSRs trading in the mid-6% range while regional tenants still hit 7.5%+. Supply stays controlled since most STNL properties come from sale-leaseback deals rather than spec development. 1031 exchange buyers keep transaction velocity steady, especially for anything with 10+ years remaining on primary term.
Market Context
Cap Rate Range
6.25% - 8.75% depending on tenant credit and lease term. Investment grade tenants with 15+ year terms trade at 6.25%-6.75%. Regional credit tenants typically 7.25%-8.75%.
Current Vacancy
2.3% functional vacancy for quality STNL properties. Most vacancy comes from tenant bankruptcies rather than new construction oversupply.
Rent Trend
Annual escalations averaging 1.75%-2.25% for new leases. Older leases with flat rent or minimal bumps create value-add opportunities through re-tenanting.
Absorption
85% of marketed STNL properties sell within 180 days. Investment grade properties typically under contract within 60 days.
Price Per Unit Trend
Not applicable for single-tenant properties. Focus on price per square foot and NOI multiples based on tenant credit quality.
Transaction Volume
$180M in STNL sales through Q3 2026, up 15% year-over-year. Average transaction size $3.2M with strong 1031 exchange participation.
Submarket Analysis
North Side (Carmel/Fishers)
6.0% - 7.25% capVacancy
1.8%
Avg Rent (1BR)
N/A - retail/service focus
Premium submarket with affluent demographics. Starbucks, Panera, and drugstore concepts perform well.
OM Tip
Highlight household income data and traffic counts on Keystone Parkway and US 31 corridors.
West Side (Avon/Plainfield)
6.5% - 8.0% capVacancy
2.1%
Avg Rent (1BR)
N/A - logistics/industrial focus
Strong logistics demand near airport. FedEx, Amazon facilities drive complementary retail demand.
OM Tip
Include proximity analysis to Hendricks County Commerce Park and Indianapolis International Airport.
South Side (Greenwood/Franklin)
7.0% - 8.5% capVacancy
2.8%
Avg Rent (1BR)
N/A - mixed retail/service
Value play with solid fundamentals. Growing residential base supports QSR and convenience retail.
OM Tip
Document population growth in Johnson County and new residential development near I-65.
East Side (Lawrence/Geist)
6.75% - 7.75% capVacancy
2.2%
Avg Rent (1BR)
N/A - neighborhood retail
Geist area commands premium rents. Mixed performance in Lawrence corridor depending on specific location.
OM Tip
Separate Geist-area properties from general Lawrence market in presentation.
Downtown/Near Downtown
7.25% - 9.0% capVacancy
3.1%
Avg Rent (1BR)
N/A - urban retail concepts
Higher cap rates reflect urban challenges but also development upside near Monument Circle and Mass Ave.
OM Tip
Include walkability scores and proximity to downtown employment centers.
Performance by Vintage
0
P
1
r
2
e
3
-
4
2
5
0
6
0
7
0
8
9
p
10
r
11
o
12
p
13
e
14
r
15
t
16
i
17
e
18
s
19
20
o
21
f
22
t
23
e
24
n
25
26
f
27
e
28
a
29
t
30
u
31
r
32
e
33
34
b
35
e
36
l
37
o
38
w
39
-
40
m
41
a
42
r
43
k
44
e
45
t
46
47
r
48
e
49
n
50
t
51
s
52
53
b
54
u
55
t
56
57
m
58
a
59
y
60
61
n
62
e
63
e
64
d
65
66
c
67
a
68
p
69
i
70
t
71
a
72
l
73
74
i
75
m
76
p
77
r
78
o
79
v
80
e
81
m
82
e
83
n
84
t
85
s
86
.
87
88
2
89
0
90
0
91
0
92
-
93
2
94
0
95
1
96
0
97
98
b
99
u
100
i
101
l
102
d
103
s
104
105
o
106
f
107
f
108
e
109
r
110
111
g
112
o
113
o
114
d
115
116
b
117
o
118
n
119
e
120
s
121
122
w
123
i
124
t
125
h
126
127
m
128
o
129
d
130
e
131
r
132
n
133
134
l
135
e
136
a
137
s
138
e
139
140
s
141
t
142
r
143
u
144
c
145
t
146
u
147
r
148
e
149
s
150
.
151
152
P
153
o
154
s
155
t
156
-
157
2
158
0
159
1
160
0
161
162
p
163
r
164
o
165
p
166
e
167
r
168
t
169
i
170
e
171
s
172
173
t
174
y
175
p
176
i
177
c
178
a
179
l
180
l
181
y
182
183
i
184
n
185
c
186
l
187
u
188
d
189
e
190
191
c
192
u
193
r
194
r
195
e
196
n
197
t
198
199
A
200
D
201
A
202
203
c
204
o
205
m
206
p
207
l
208
i
209
a
210
n
211
c
212
e
213
214
a
215
n
216
d
217
218
e
219
n
220
e
221
r
222
g
223
y
224
225
e
226
f
227
f
228
i
229
c
230
i
231
e
232
n
233
c
234
y
235
236
f
237
e
238
a
239
t
240
u
241
r
242
e
243
s
244
.
245
246
N
247
e
248
w
249
250
c
251
o
252
n
253
s
254
t
255
r
256
u
257
c
258
t
259
i
260
o
261
n
262
263
S
264
T
265
N
266
L
267
268
r
269
a
270
r
271
e
272
273
e
274
x
275
c
276
e
277
p
278
t
279
280
f
281
o
282
r
283
284
b
285
u
286
i
287
l
288
d
289
-
290
t
291
o
292
-
293
s
294
u
295
i
296
t
297
298
a
299
r
300
r
301
a
302
n
303
g
304
e
305
m
306
e
307
n
308
t
309
s
310
311
w
312
i
313
t
314
h
315
316
c
317
r
318
e
319
d
320
i
321
t
322
323
t
324
e
325
n
326
a
327
n
328
t
329
s
330
331
r
332
e
333
q
334
u
335
i
336
r
337
i
338
n
339
g
340
341
s
342
p
343
e
344
c
345
i
346
f
347
i
348
c
349
350
l
351
o
352
c
353
a
354
t
355
i
356
o
357
n
358
s
359
.
What Your OM Needs to Address
Full lease abstract with critical dates
Include all renewal options, rent escalation schedule, and assignment/subletting provisions. Many buyers get burned by missing renewal deadlines or below-market resets.
Data to Include
Lease commencement date, expiration date, all option periods with deadlines, escalation percentages and dates, renewal rent calculation methodology.
Go-dark and continuous operation clauses
Essential for retail tenants who might close location but continue rent payments. Continuous operation requirements protect against dark stores hurting property value.
Data to Include
Specific continuous operation language, go-dark provisions, remedies for cessation of business operations, co-tenancy requirements if applicable.
Tenant financial performance and guarantor strength
Include three years of tenant financial statements plus guarantor info. Local/regional tenants require deeper financial analysis than national credit tenants.
Data to Include
Tenant and guarantor financial statements, credit ratings if available, sales performance at subject location, comparable store sales data.
Triple net expense reconciliation
Show actual CAM, insurance, and tax expenses vs. tenant reimbursements. Many buyers underestimate true net cash flow after expense reconciliation shortfalls.
Data to Include
Three years of operating expense statements, tenant reimbursement calculations, any landlord expense responsibilities not passed through.
Environmental and zoning compliance
Include Phase I environmental report and zoning compliance letter. Many STNL properties have previous gas station or auto service history requiring disclosure.
Data to Include
Phase I environmental assessment, zoning compliance certification, permitted use documentation, any environmental remediation history.
Market rent analysis and re-leasing assumptions
Document current market rents for space if tenant doesn't renew. Include analysis of alternative use potential and re-leasing timeline assumptions.
Data to Include
Comparable lease rates for similar spaces, broker opinion of market rent, estimated downtime and leasing costs for re-tenanting, alternative use feasibility.
Investment Outlook
Short Term
Continued yield compression for investment grade tenants as institutional capital seeks income. Regional tenants offer better returns but face potential credit pressures from economic uncertainty. Transaction velocity should remain strong through 2026.
Medium Term
Interest rate environment will determine cap rate direction over next 2-3 years. Indianapolis' diverse economy provides stability but won't drive outsized rent growth. Expect continued sale-leaseback activity from regional operators.
Long Term
Demographics favor continued retail demand in suburban corridors. Industrial growth along I-70 and near airport should support service retail. Downtown properties face longer-term uncertainty around office worker return and urban retail viability.
Buyer Profile
Mix of 1031 exchange buyers (40%), private investors seeking income (35%), and institutional buyers for credit tenants (25%). Local buyers understand market nuances better than out-of-state capital.
Marketing a single-tenant net lease property in Indianapolis?
DealDraft generates professional offering memorandums with market-specific data and property-type expertise built in.
Create Your OM