Retail Investment in New York
New York retail's split into two stories. Prime street retail in Manhattan still commands top dollar, but secondary locations are getting hammered. Cap rates have compressed on grocery-anchored centers while fashion retail sits empty. The flight to quality is real - institutional money wants food, services, and experiential concepts. Everything else is value-add territory.
Market Context
Cap Rate Range
4.2% to 7.8% depending on location and tenant mix
Current Vacancy
12.8% overall, with Manhattan street retail at 16.2%
Rent Trend
Down 18% from peak in Manhattan, stable in outer borough grocery-anchored centers
Absorption
Negative 2.1 million SF annually over past 24 months
Price Per Unit Trend
Price per SF down 22% for street retail, up 8% for neighborhood centers
Transaction Volume
$2.8 billion in retail sales through Q3 2025, down from $4.1 billion in 2019
Submarket Analysis
Manhattan Street Retail
5.8% to 7.8% capVacancy
16.2%
Avg Rent (1BR)
$185 to $650 per SF
Stabilizing but tenant quality matters more than ever
OM Tip
Must address co-tenancy risks and any upcoming lease rollovers
Brooklyn Neighborhood Centers
4.8% to 6.2% capVacancy
8.4%
Avg Rent (1BR)
$45 to $85 per SF
Strong fundamentals driven by residential growth
OM Tip
Highlight walkability scores and demographic trends
Queens Strip Centers
5.2% to 6.8% capVacancy
11.1%
Avg Rent (1BR)
$38 to $72 per SF
Value play with upside if you can improve tenant mix
OM Tip
Focus on parking ratios and public transit access
Bronx Community Centers
6.5% to 8.1% capVacancy
14.3%
Avg Rent (1BR)
$28 to $48 per SF
Highest yields but requires active management
OM Tip
Document any recent capital improvements and security measures
Staten Island Shopping Centers
5.8% to 7.2% capVacancy
9.7%
Avg Rent (1BR)
$32 to $58 per SF
Stable but limited buyer pool
OM Tip
Emphasize car accessibility and suburban demographics
Performance by Vintage
0
P
1
r
2
e
3
-
4
1
5
9
6
8
7
0
8
9
b
10
u
11
i
12
l
13
d
14
i
15
n
16
g
17
s
18
19
n
20
e
21
e
22
d
23
24
s
25
e
26
r
27
i
28
o
29
u
30
s
31
32
c
33
a
34
p
35
i
36
t
37
a
38
l
39
40
b
41
u
42
t
43
44
o
45
f
46
f
47
e
48
r
49
50
r
51
e
52
d
53
e
54
v
55
e
56
l
57
o
58
p
59
m
60
e
61
n
62
t
63
64
p
65
o
66
t
67
e
68
n
69
t
70
i
71
a
72
l
73
.
74
75
1
76
9
77
8
78
0
79
s
80
-
81
1
82
9
83
9
84
0
85
s
86
87
s
88
t
89
r
90
i
91
p
92
93
c
94
e
95
n
96
t
97
e
98
r
99
s
100
101
a
102
r
103
e
104
105
t
106
h
107
e
108
109
s
110
w
111
e
112
e
113
t
114
115
s
116
p
117
o
118
t
119
120
-
121
122
g
123
o
124
o
125
d
126
127
b
128
o
129
n
130
e
131
s
132
,
133
134
m
135
a
136
n
137
a
138
g
139
e
140
a
141
b
142
l
143
e
144
145
d
146
e
147
f
148
e
149
r
150
r
151
e
152
d
153
154
m
155
a
156
i
157
n
158
t
159
e
160
n
161
a
162
n
163
c
164
e
165
.
166
167
2
168
0
169
0
170
0
171
s
172
173
p
174
o
175
w
176
e
177
r
178
179
c
180
e
181
n
182
t
183
e
184
r
185
s
186
187
a
188
r
189
e
190
191
s
192
t
193
r
194
u
195
g
196
g
197
l
198
i
199
n
200
g
201
202
w
203
i
204
t
205
h
206
207
o
208
v
209
e
210
r
211
s
212
i
213
z
214
e
215
d
216
217
a
218
n
219
c
220
h
221
o
222
r
223
224
b
225
o
226
x
227
e
228
s
229
.
230
231
P
232
o
233
s
234
t
235
-
236
2
237
0
238
1
239
0
240
241
m
242
i
243
x
244
e
245
d
246
-
247
u
248
s
249
e
250
251
p
252
r
253
o
254
j
255
e
256
c
257
t
258
s
259
260
c
261
o
262
m
263
m
264
a
265
n
266
d
267
268
p
269
r
270
e
271
m
272
i
273
u
274
m
275
s
276
277
i
278
f
279
280
t
281
h
282
e
283
y
284
'
285
r
286
e
287
288
t
289
r
290
a
291
n
292
s
293
i
294
t
295
-
296
o
297
r
298
i
299
e
300
n
301
t
302
e
303
d
304
.
What Your OM Needs to Address
Tenant Sales Data
Include 3-year sales per SF for all tenants paying percentage rent
Data to Include
Monthly sales reports, CAM recoveries, actual vs. projected percentage rent collections
Co-tenancy Clauses
Document all kick-out rights and occupancy thresholds
Data to Include
Specific lease language, current occupancy levels, historical co-tenancy violations
Anchor Lease Terms
Many grocery anchors have below-market rents locked in for decades
Data to Include
Rent rolls with escalations, renewal options, assignment rights
CAM Reconciliation
Show 3 years of CAM charges and recoveries by tenant
Data to Include
Annual CAM budgets, actual expenses, tenant reimbursement rates
Traffic Counts
Include pedestrian and vehicle counts for the past 24 months
Data to Include
Daily/weekly traffic patterns, seasonal variations, nearby transit ridership
Zoning and Use Rights
Document permitted uses and any special zoning allowances
Data to Include
Zoning certificates, permitted use schedules, any variances or special permits
Investment Outlook
Short Term
Buyer selectivity continues through 2026. Grocery-anchored centers will trade at compression while fashion retail remains distressed. Interest rate cuts should help transaction volume but won't fix fundamental tenant demand issues.
Medium Term
Experiential retail concepts will drive the next cycle. Food halls, fitness, and services replace traditional retail. Expect more mixed-use redevelopment in outer boroughs as zoning relaxes. Value-add opportunities in secondary locations.
Long Term
New York retail becomes increasingly bifurcated. Prime locations with experiential tenants perform like trophy office. Everything else becomes neighborhood convenience or gets redeveloped. Climate regulations will force major capital investment in older properties.
Buyer Profile
REITs want grocery-anchored assets in Brooklyn and Queens. Private equity is hunting distressed street retail for conversion plays. Family offices are buying single-tenant net lease properties with credit tenants. Foreign capital has stepped back significantly.
Marketing a retail property in New York?
DealDraft generates professional offering memorandums with market-specific data and property-type expertise built in.
Create Your OM